Saturday, December 08, 2007

The Dishonesty Of Recording Industry Statistics

With rumors flying in Canada that we will have a new copyright law before the house of commons in the next few weeks, it's perhaps interesting to see the logic (or lack of it) from the various members of the recording industry in Canada.

The Canadian songwriters guild proposed that our internet access accounts should be levied a flat fee of $5 or so per month for the privilege of downloading music. The CBC interviewed some nitwit from the organization making this proposal, and he made the bald statement that "70% of internet traffic is downloads".

Superficially, this may in fact be true. When you open a web page, and a pile of graphics are on that page - or even raw text, triggers a series of downloads from the host server to your desktop. Sure, 70% of the traffic is downloads using measurements like that. How much of that 70% are "illegitimate" copying of music or video content?

I know myself, I download relatively little, if any music - and what little I do download tends to come from legitimate, legal sources that I already pay for! I also download some software - all of it "Open Source" and perfectly legitimate. So...the question that comes to my mind is this - why should I pay these twits money for the privilege of something I don't even do? I already pay these bastards every time I purchase a hard drive or other recordable media.

The notion of an "across the board levy" is nothing more than a form of taxation - and it is one that I resent. While the government legally has the right to levy taxes, I dispute whether it has any right to levy specific taxes on behalf of an industry. Not only is it corporate welfare in the most noxious way, but it further punishes people for the supposition of wrong doing.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Just a quick note, according to a website slashdot.org the Canadian version of the DMCA was pulled yesterday.

http://politics.slashdot.org/article.pl?
sid=07/12/10/2357247


This is not a real victory for those of us who simply want to enjoy our legally purchased music, just a tactical retreat on the part of the Cons to revamp a piece of legislation that is at best questionable, at worst technical serfdom for the average user.

Go to the following website if you really want to make a point to be heard by Ottawa. Follow the suggestions and contact your MP, the listed Ministers and tell them 'NO' to that type of legislation.

http://www.michaelgeist.ca/index.php?option=
com_content&task=view&id=1447&Itemid=125


Unless you want to spend the rest of your life giving your hard earned money to the slackers in the music industry.

E.

Collective Punishment

Ever since Pierre Poilievre opened his mouth and declared that Trans Women need to be banned from washrooms and locker rooms , there's b...