Showing posts with label Confederation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Confederation. Show all posts

Thursday, December 25, 2025

So, Queen Dani Doesn't Like Courts?

In a year-end interview, Premier Smith of Alberta complained that "judges aren't accountable", and elected politicians are.  

Like everything else that comes out of today's conservative politicians, this is 1 part truth, 9 parts lie.  Accountability takes many forms, and to frame elections as the only legitimate kind of accountability in our system of government is simply false.  It's convenient for her in the moment, but when she then turns around and complains that "people are abusing recall", one does have to wonder exactly how sincere she really is.  

Do we have confidence that our judiciary is reflective of the values that we have in our province? Because most of our judiciary is appointed by the federal government, and we’ve had 10 years of judges being appointed by Justin Trudeau; When you see ideology getting into these judgments and the judges, they don’t face the electorate the way we do

Smith complains that "we've had 10 years of Justin Trudeau appointing judges", and that "...ideology getting into these judgements ...".  What she's really doing is misrepresenting the process through which judges are appointed in this country, as well as the nature of how judgments are written - judges actually explain their reasoning in their rulings, something that politicians seldom bother with.

If the court is going to continue to go down a certain path, and I think, be unreasonable in some of its judgments, and not be deferential to the decisions and the (reasons) elected decision makers are making their policy decisions, they should expect that more legislatures are going to use the notwithstanding clause

Poilievre's Plummeting Polling

The CPC is polling just a hair below 30% , and Pierre Poilievre's "favourability" as next PM is now tied with "Undecided...